From: Berhane Habtemariam (Berhane.Habtemariam@gmx.de)
Date: Thu Apr 15 2010 - 07:01:05 EDT
<http://farmlandgrab.org/12160> Poor plundered for land
Published: 15 April 2010
Posted in: <http://farmlandgrab.org/cat/Olivier%20de%20Schutter> Olivier de
Schutter
<http://farmlandgrab.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/spooner_1504_main-420x0.
jpg> (Illustration: Spooner)
(Illustration: Spooner)
The Age | April 15, 2010
JO CHANDLER
Farmers in Africa may starve as their fields are bought to profit rich
foreigners.
WHEN people accustomed to foraging in supermarkets venture into the
developing world, one of the great shocks is the visibility of the food
chain - the pungent, intimate connectedness of land, animals and people.
Chickens scratch at rubbish heaps. Children tend livestock. Women work the
fields. Consumer culture obscures such realities - the sweat, the
slaughterhouse, the sleepless anxiety of waiting on good rains and fair
prices. We don't know the stories of where food comes from, and are
disinclined to ask.
But as competition for food increases in a warming, drying, more populous
world, the unappetising depths of the labyrinthine food chain and the
markets that sustain us deserve our scrutiny. Do we dare look?
Since the 2008 global food crisis, some of the world's hungriest nations
have been targeted in a land rush by billionaires, investment funds, banks,
speculators and states looking for arable land to produce food for export,
for profit, for bio-fuels, and to secure their larders in an uncertain
world.
In sub-Saharan Africa, nations identified in a new United Nations report as
being fossicked for their acreage include Ethiopia, the Democratic Republic
of Congo, Sudan and Somalia - countries etched into consciousness for their
cycles of ravenous hunger.
The same desolate landscapes familiar as the backdrop for stories of
scarcity and suffering are now greedily eyed by big agriculture as fields
for feeding the 9 billion people expected to inhabit the planet by 2050.
More people, finite land, and everyone must eat. As an analysis of the
agribusiness bonanza in Der Spiegel observed, every crisis has its winners.
Land prospectors are also busy in Latin America, Central Europe and Asia.
But Africa is the focus. Land is cheap and much of it untitled, even if it
has been worked for generations by farming smallholders. It's close to rich
markets. It lies within reach of precious water which rudimentary systems
could never plunder. All it takes to become productive is massive investment
in irrigation, high-tech seeds, fertilisers, precision farming and transport
links. All the things locals might long have wished for to improve their
lives.
For years the UN, the World Bank and development agencies have solicited for
agricultural investment in the developing world. Now the concern is how to
ensure the windfall does more good than harm.
In late 2008, as the rush gained steam, the head of the UN Food and
Agriculture Organisation warned it could create "neo-colonialism", with poor
states producing food for the rich at the expense of their own hungry. Since
then, the FAO line has fallen into sync with the World Bank to encourage
farm investment while, behind the scenes, agencies search for mechanisms to
ensure that small farmers aren't sacrificed to agribusiness margins.
An investigation published last month by the UN Special Rapporteur on the
right to food, Olivier De Schutter, recognises that agribusiness presents
opportunities in the developing world - for markets, jobs, infrastructure
and food. But it also raises human rights challenges, particularly where it
ignores local land rights, he says. The tenor of his report is cautious,
concerned, and appeals for the world to set caveats to protect the
vulnerable from voracious market appetites.
De Schutter said he was "extremely doubtful and worried" by recent
transactions involving maybe 20 million hectares of land. An investigation
by the London Observer puts the figure at closer to 50 million hectares. The
lease deals are often invisible, brokered by governments without
consultation with their parliaments or with the people on the land.
"The human right to food would be violated if people depending on land for
their livelihoods . were cut off from access to land," De Schutter says. An
increasingly globalised food sector dominated by big corporate muscle puts
small farmers at a pitiful disadvantage when they sell their crops. If they
complain, they risk reprisal. "These imbalances of power in the food systems
can and must be corrected."
The sort of forces underwriting his anxieties are plain in Der Spiegel's
report, which includes startlingly candid observations from the boardroom.
"When food becomes scarce, the investor needs a weak state that does not
force him to abide by any rules," says a New York investor now with a big
stake in Sudan - the world's largest recipient of aid. He argues his project
will not only profit him, but deliver more jobs and food than the UN ever
could.
In Ethiopia, where more than 13 million people need food aid, the government
is offering 3 million hectares of fertile land to investors in the hope of
modernising and capitalising. African governments are competing to entice
investors with favourable deals instead of banding together to insist on
safeguards for their citizens. "What is different about this colonialism is
that countries are readily allowing themselves to be conquered," Der Spiegel
observes.
Recognising that food is critical not just to wellbeing but to social and
political stability, De Schutter urges a list of principles for all large
land acquisitions or leases. They should be transparent; brokered with the
consent of communities; pay benefits to the population; promote jobs and
fair pay; respect the environment; protect local food security; and
recognise indigenous land claims.
But if governments fail their citizens, and if corporates fail to recognise
the rights of the people hosting them, then De Schutter asks the investors'
home constituency, the wealthy, to apply due diligence. In a hungrier world,
obligation falls on consumers of investment products, stockmarket gains and
food to ask: where did this bounty come from?
Jo Chandler is a senior writer.
----[This List to be used for Eritrea Related News Only]----